If you are claiming the R&D Tax Incentive, you have three broad options: do it yourself, engage a consultant, or use software with expert review. They cost very differently, and the headline rate is not the whole story. As someone who reviews claims for a living, here is an honest comparison, including where each option genuinely wins.
A disclaimer worth stating up front
The R&DTI is a self-assessment program and no provider can guarantee an outcome. This is general information, not financial or tax advice. The right choice depends on your specific circumstances, and you should seek independent advice for them.
What are your options for running a claim?
Three: do it yourself, engage a traditional consultant, or use software with built-in expert review. They differ on cost, effort, and the quality of evidence they produce.
Do it yourself. You self-assess, register with AusIndustry, and claim through your tax return. Cost is your time and the risk of getting it wrong. Workable for very simple claims, painful and risky as soon as the activities or financials get involved. See the software eligibility guide to gauge whether your claim is simple enough.
Traditional consultant. A firm prepares the claim for you. A common fee model is a percentage of your R&D benefit, sometimes with a retainer up front. You get expertise and offload the work. Ask how often the firm engages with you during the year and how it gathers evidence.
Software with expert review. A platform drafts the claim from the work you already do and an Expert Reviewer reviews it. Pricing is structured differently. Evidence is captured continuously rather than reconstructed at year end.
How do the costs compare?
Rand's fees are on its pricing page. The left column lists what to ask any consultant:
| Ask a consultant | Rand (published) | |
|---|---|---|
| Pricing model | Fee basis and rate, in dollars on your numbers | Tiered 10% to 5% of the R&D benefit by spend bracket |
| Upfront cost | Any retainer or setup fee | None |
| When you pay | When fees fall due | Only after the benefit is issued |
| Evidence prep | How and when evidence is gathered | Drafted from your tools through the year |
| Turnaround | When drafting happens | Through the year |
| Expert review | Who reviews the registration | Expert Reviewer built in |
Fee rates and bases differ, so compare the dollar fee on your own numbers. For an early-stage company, the timing matters too: paying nothing up front and nothing until the benefit lands is very different from a retainer plus a percentage.
Watch the fee base
A flat percentage of the benefit and a marginal, bracketed percentage (lower rates on higher spend, like tax brackets) give different dollar fees at different claim sizes. Always model the actual dollar fee on your numbers, not just the headline rate.
When is a consultant the right choice?
When the claim needs bespoke judgement that software cannot standardise. A traditional consultant is the right call when:
- Your claim is unusually complex, multiple entities, overseas activities, or contested eligibility that needs bespoke legal judgement.
- You want a single named adviser to own the engagement end to end and represent you directly.
- You have no interest in any involvement and will pay a premium to hand it off entirely.
The trade-off to weigh: compare the dollar fee on your numbers, and ask how and when the evidence will be gathered.
When does software fit better?
For many straightforward software-company claims, it captures evidence as the work happens and keeps the claim current through the year.
- Cost, depending on your numbers: compare the dollar fee each way.
- Evidence quality. Capturing the experimental trail continuously, from your pull requests, issues, and time records, produces stronger, contemporaneous evidence than a year-end reconstruction. That matters more every year, and especially under the proposed 2028 reforms, which would narrow the program toward a well-evidenced core. See documenting a defensible claim.
- It stays current. The claim is kept current through the year, not a once-a-year sprint.
Rand's model is deliberately a blend: AI drafts the claim, you review it, and an Expert Reviewer (in our case, me) approves it before your company submits it. You get expert judgement within a tiered Service Fee, and an evidence trail built as you work rather than rebuilt at the end.
The bottom line
For a complex, contested, or multi-entity claim, a specialist consultant may be the better fit. For many Australian software companies, software with built-in expert review can suit, provided its dollar fee and evidence process work for you. Model the actual fee on your numbers, look hard at the quality of the evidence each option produces, and weigh the 2028 changes when you decide.
The R&D Tax Incentive is a self-assessment scheme. Rand helps you prepare and document a defensible claim but cannot submit on your behalf and does not guarantee any outcome. This is general information, not tax, legal, or financial advice.
