Comparisons

Can your accountant do your R&D claim? Yes, and here is where Rand fits

Yes. Your accountant can prepare the whole claim, and usually prepares the ATO half: the R&D schedule and company tax return. The question is the AusIndustry registration, which turns on technical evidence. If your accountant writes registrations regularly and your activities are few and well recorded, they may need no one else.

Reviewed by George WalchFacts last verified

Rand with your accountant and Your accountant alone side by side

Rand with your accountant compared with Your accountant alone
FactRand with your accountantYour accountant alone
AusIndustry registrationRand prepares it from your records; your company declares and submits itYour accountant prepares it with you; your company declares it
ATO R&D schedule and tax returnYour accountant, from Rand's handoff letterYour accountant
Technical review of activitiesYour team, then an Expert ReviewerYour accountant and your team, unless a specialist is brought in
Turnover, offset type and tax positionYour accountantYour accountant
FeesRand's share of the benefit plus your accountant's usual fee for the returnOne fee, set by your accountant
Best fitSeveral activities, records spread across engineering tools, or an accountant who rarely writes registrationsFew, well-recorded activities and an accountant experienced with registrations

Can you use both?

This is the normal arrangement rather than an alternative. Rand prepares the registration, your company submits it, and your accountant uses the registration number and Rand's handoff letter (the submitted expenditure and its breakdown) to prepare the schedule and return. Neither replaces the other.

Every R&D Tax Incentive claim has two halves and two regulators. Your accountant is central to one of them whichever way you go.

The two halves of a claim

The registration goes to the department (AusIndustry) within 10 months of the year end. It describes each core and supporting activity: the uncertainty, the hypothesis, the experiments and what was learned. It is a technical document, and the ATO itself says it cannot help with questions about registration or the eligibility of activities.

The claim goes to the ATO. The company completes the R&D tax incentive schedule and the relevant labels of its company tax return, and must quote that year's registration number on the schedule. This is accountant territory: the ATO's own first checks are whether the company is an R&D entity, whether it registered, and whether its notional deductions are at least $20,000 (below that, only amounts paid to a registered research service provider that is not an associate, and Cooperative Research Centre contributions, earn an offset). Then comes aggregated turnover, which counts connected entities (control generally starts at 40%, with statutory exceptions) and affiliates, Australian and foreign, and decides whether the offset is refundable.

How the handoff works with Rand

Rand works on the first half and stops at the boundary:

  1. AI drafts the registration from your GitHub, Jira, Linear and Notion records and Xero payroll.
  2. Your team reviews it and an Expert Reviewer finalises it.
  3. Your company declares and submits it, and receives the registration number.
  4. Rand delivers your company a handoff letter for your accountant, with the submitted R&D expenditure and its breakdown and the submission and registration details, together with AusIndustry's confirmation.
  5. Your accountant applies the tax law, confirms what is claimed, and prepares the schedule and return.

Rand is not a tax agent and does not prepare the schedule or the return.

When your accountant alone is enough

Plenty of companies need no one else. Four signs:

  • Your accountant prepares R&D registrations every year, not occasionally.
  • You have one or two clearly bounded core activities, not a portfolio.
  • Your records are already organised by activity, with hypotheses and results written down at the time.
  • The claim is small enough that a second set of fees takes a large share of the benefit.

If all four hold, keep it with your accountant.

Questions to ask your accountant first

  • How many R&D registrations did you prepare last year, and in which sectors?
  • Who reads the activity descriptions for technical accuracy before we declare them?
  • Will you collect evidence during the year, or only after it ends?
  • If the department examines the registration, who answers the statement of issues, and how is that charged?

Their answers tell you whether to leave the registration with them or bring in a specialist for that half. If they write registrations rarely, or your evidence is scattered across engineering tools, a specialist on the registration can be worth its cost: compare the fee in dollars with the hours and risk it removes under the engagement you are offered. The general trade-off is set out in specialist adviser vs generalist accountant, and accountants who want tools of their own can see R&D tax software for accountants.

Frequently asked questions

How does my accountant work with what Rand prepares?
The ATO-side work stays with them: the schedule, the return and the turnover and offset questions. Rand's handoff letter sets out the submitted expenditure and its breakdown with the registration details. Your accountant still applies the tax law and decides what is claimed, so ask them early how they want to receive it.
Does my accountant need to be registered to help with the R&D claim?
The ATO advises that if you use a tax agent to help with returns or the registration, you should check that their registration is current on the Tax Practitioners Board register. Rand is not a tax agent and does not prepare the return.
Who answers if AusIndustry asks for evidence?
The company, usually helped by whoever prepared the registration. Requests normally allow 30 days. With Rand, help with an AusIndustry or ATO review is billed at $350 an hour excluding GST; ask your accountant how they would charge for the same work.
Can the fee for preparing the registration be included in the claim?
No. The ATO says accountant or consultant fees for preparing the registration or the tax return that claims the incentive cannot be notionally deducted, whoever does the work.

Sources

  1. ATO: Steps for claiming R&D tax offset
  2. ATO: Research and development tax incentive advice and feedback
  3. ATO: Expenditure you can claim (accountant and consultant fees)

The R&D Tax Incentive is a self-assessment program. This page is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice; eligibility depends on your circumstances and you should seek independent advice for them.