Comparisons

R&D tax specialist or generalist accountant: who should lead which part of the claim

Use a specialist when the risk sits in the activities: drawing R&D boundaries, writing hypotheses and experiments, and avoiding whole-of-project software claims. Use your accountant when the risk sits in the entity or the numbers: turnover grouping, offset rate, associates, apportionment and grants. Most claims need both, with one clearly in charge.

Reviewed by George WalchFacts last verified

Specialist R&D adviser and Generalist accountant side by side

Specialist R&D adviser compared with Generalist accountant
FactSpecialist R&D adviserGeneralist accountant
Home groundThe activity criteria in sections 355-25 and 355-30, and AusIndustry practiceThe company's books, tax position and the ATO side of the claim
Strongest onSplitting a project into core and supporting activities and writing each oneAggregated turnover, offset rate, expenditure and the tax return
Ask them aboutHow they check group structure, associate payments and how the offset interacts with tax lossesHow they tell an experiment from routine development in a technical field
Staff backgroundOften engineers or scientists alongside tax staffAccountants and tax agents
Knows your businessFrom the engagement, usually once a yearAll year, from bookkeeping, payroll and prior returns
Who prepares the ATO scheduleOnly if the firm is also a registered tax agentYes, with the return

Can you use both?

Yes, and it is a common arrangement for larger claims. The specialist leads the registration and the activity evidence; the accountant leads turnover, the offset rate, apportionment and the schedule. Agree early who owns the expenditure figures so the two halves reconcile.

The R&D Tax Incentive is run by two agencies, and the expertise splits the same way. The department decides whether activities are eligible. The ATO administers the expenditure and the offset, and says plainly that it cannot help with registration or activity eligibility questions. A claim can fail on either side.

Where a specialist earns the fee

Eligibility rests on the legislated criteria in sections 355-25 and 355-30 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997. Applying them well is technical work. The ATO and the department list what they see go wrong in software claims:

  • claims made on a whole-of-project basis rather than activity by activity;
  • software experiments not clearly articulated in the registration;
  • technical uncertainties not identified;
  • the cost of acquiring or licensing technology claimed as R&D;
  • expenditure apportioned between R&D and other work unreasonably.

The first three are a specialist's territory. The software taxpayer alert, TA 2017/5, turns on the same points, and a good specialist will draw the line between core and supporting work before writing a word.

Where your accountant is the expert

The other half of the risk is in the entity and the numbers, and your accountant sees it all year:

  • Turnover grouping. Connected entities and affiliates count, Australian and foreign, and decide whether the offset is refundable.
  • Offset rate. Under $20 million aggregated turnover, and not controlled by exempt entities, the refundable offset is the tax rate plus 18.5 points: 43.5% for a base rate entity, 48.5% for a company taxed at 30%. A company whose assessable income is more than 80% passive, such as a pre-revenue company living on interest, is not a base rate entity. Above that turnover the non-refundable rate turns on the tax rate and R&D intensity.
  • Associates. Amounts owed to an associate count only once paid, the issue behind TA 2023/4.
  • At-risk spend. Under s 355-405, expenditure is not claimable to the extent a guaranteed return or an indemnity covers it; TR 2021/5 sets out the ATO's view.
  • Apportionment. The ATO's example: R&D salary over total staff may suit personnel costs, but not utilities.

Records decide disputes on both sides

The ATO points to two tribunal decisions, Tier Toys [2014] AATA 156 and Ozone Manufacturing [2013] AATA 420, where the company had no contemporaneous records and could not show the spending was more than ordinary business expense. Neither a specialist nor an accountant can fix that after the year ends, so whoever you choose should be asking about records kept at the time early.

Who should lead

Let the specialist lead when the risk is in the activities: several projects, novel technical work, or a history of whole-of-project claims. Let the accountant lead when the risk is in the entity or the numbers: groups, foreign owners, associates or grants. For a single, well-documented activity, an experienced accountant can do both. Rand vs your accountant shows how Rand covers the specialist half without touching the tax return, and best advisers for SaaS companies compares specialists directly.

Frequently asked questions

Can a specialist R&D adviser prepare my tax return as well?
Some can, where the firm is also a registered tax agent; others cannot. The ATO advises that if you use a tax agent for returns or the registration, you check their registration is current on the Tax Practitioners Board register.
Is a specialist worth it for a first, small claim?
Often not, if your accountant has done registrations before and the work is one clear activity. The specialist earns their fee where activity boundaries are hard to draw or the claim is large enough that an examination would be costly.
Who decides whether an activity is eligible?
Neither adviser. The company self-assesses, the department decides eligibility if it examines the activities, and the ATO administers the expenditure and offset. Advisers help you get the self-assessment right, but the declaration stays with the company.

Sources

  1. ATO: Helping you get R&D claims right (software, apportionment, associates, records)
  2. ATO: Research and development tax incentive advice and feedback (who answers what)
  3. business.gov.au: Assuring integrity in the R&D Tax Incentive (legislated criteria)

The R&D Tax Incentive is a self-assessment program. This page is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice; eligibility depends on your circumstances and you should seek independent advice for them.