Comparisons

Advance finding or annual registration: what the extra certainty buys

In our experience most companies need only the annual registration. An advance finding is an optional, legally binding eligibility decision for up to three years, worth seeking when an activity is large, novel or likely to be questioned. It must be applied for before the income year ends and never replaces registering each year.

Reviewed by George WalchFacts last verified

Annual registration only and Advance finding plus registration side by side

Annual registration only compared with Advance finding plus registration
FactAnnual registration onlyAdvance finding plus registration
Required?Yes, every income year you want to claimOptional; the yearly registration is still required
Deadline10 months after the income year ends, with limited extensionsBefore the income year ends, with no extensions at all
What the department decidesRegisters the activities; registration does not confirm eligibilityMakes a binding finding that each activity is eligible, partly eligible or ineligible
How long it lastsOne income yearUp to 3 years from the income year of the application, while the activity matches the certificate
Covers expenditure?No; the company and its accountant self-assess amounts with the ATONo; an ATO private ruling is the route for expenditure questions
Typical waitService target: 95% processed within 20, 40 or 80 business days, depending on timing and first-time statusAverage of 90 days, affected by timing, completeness and replies to information requests
Best suited toMost claims with well-documented, routine-sized activitiesLarge, novel or borderline activities, or claims a lender or investor will rely on

Can you use both?

They are designed to work together. A positive advance finding sits under the yearly registration: you still register the activities each year, quote the certificate number in the application, and reference the finding when claiming with the ATO. If the finding has not arrived by the registration deadline, include the activities anyway: adding them by variation is only possible before the statutory deadline, and after it the route is an extension of time and a withdrawn and resubmitted application.

The annual registration is the program. An advance finding is an add-on that turns self-assessment into a binding answer on eligibility, for work done, under way or planned in the year you apply and planned for the next two. That is valuable for some activities and unnecessary for most.

How the annual route works

Each year the company registers its core and supporting activities within 10 months of the year end and then claims the offset through its tax return. The R&D Tax Incentive is self-assessed: confirmation of registration does not mean the activities are eligible. AusIndustry can examine an application before registering it or afterwards, a post-registration finding can reach current and earlier years, and the ATO can review the expenditure after the claim. For most well-run software and life science claims that is an acceptable risk, managed with good contemporaneous evidence.

What an advance finding adds

An advance finding is a decision by the department on the eligibility of described activities, made before you register them. Each activity comes back eligible, partly eligible or ineligible, and a copy of the notice goes to the ATO. A positive finding binds for up to three years: the income year you apply in and the next two. It can cover activities already done in that year, planned for it, or expected in either of the next two years. An activity already completed when you apply has no later years for the finding to cover.

Its limits matter as much as its strength:

  • It covers activities, not expenditure.
  • If the activity materially changes and no longer matches the certificate's description, the finding no longer applies and a new application is needed.
  • It can be refused in circumstances set out in Part 4 of the Decision-making Principles 2022.
  • An activity still running after the third year can be the subject of a new application.

When the extra step is worth it

An advance finding earns its preparation time when the answer changes a decision:

  1. A multi-year program whose spend is large enough that losing eligibility would hurt.
  2. Work close to an exclusion, such as software for internal administration or activities in a production environment.
  3. A company raising capital or taking R&D finance against the expected refund, where a binding view helps the other side.
  4. Clinical work, where the Clinical Trials Determination can simplify the application.

It is rarely worth it for small, routine claims, or for activities that will change shape quickly.

Timing in practice

For a 30 June year end the advance finding must be in by 30 June of the year the work happens, while the registration for the same year is due the following 30 April. With an average 90-day decision time, apply early in the year. Overseas work follows its own rule: an overseas finding is mandatory, not optional, before claiming that spend.

Whichever route you take, the annual registration is still yours to declare and submit. Rand prepares it from your records for your team and an Expert Reviewer to check. Companies weighing up who should prepare an advance finding application can compare specialist advisers and accountants.

Frequently asked questions

Can I apply for an advance finding after 30 June for last year's work?
No. For a 30 June year end, the application must be in before 30 June of the year the activities are conducted or planned. The department cannot accept late applications or grant extensions for advance findings under any circumstances, unlike the registration itself.
Does a positive advance finding mean the ATO will accept my figures?
No. Advance findings cover the eligibility of activities only, not the expenditure claimed against them. Questions about how tax law treats particular amounts go to the ATO, which offers early engagement and binding private rulings for complex cases.
What if AusIndustry finds my activity ineligible?
You can ask for an internal review within 28 days of being notified, then seek external review at the Administrative Review Tribunal. An unfavourable finding before you register at least tells you not to claim the activity, which is cheaper than finding out in a later examination.
Is there a fee to apply?
The business.gov.au advance finding page lists no application fee. The real cost is the time to write a complete application with supporting documents, and any adviser fee for preparing it.

Sources

  1. business.gov.au: Apply for an advance finding from the R&D Tax Incentive
  2. business.gov.au: Decisions we make about R&D Tax Incentive applications
  3. ATO: Research and development tax incentive advice and feedback (private rulings)

The R&D Tax Incentive is a self-assessment program. This page is general information, not tax, legal or financial advice; eligibility depends on your circumstances and you should seek independent advice for them.